Penske
vs. U-Haul.
Compare one-way truck rental structures, mileage, truck sizes and the extra charges that change your final quote.
Long-distance and local truck rentals
Updated October 28, 2026
The short answer: Penske and U-Haul both offer one-way moving trucks, but their rental structures differ. Penske currently advertises unlimited mileage on one-way truck rentals, while U-Haul one-way truck rentals include an allowed mileage and a set number of days. Actual prices and availability vary by route, truck size and date, so compare quotes for the same move before choosing.
Penske vs. U-Haul: Key Differences
| Feature | Penske | U-Haul |
|---|---|---|
| One-way truck mileage | Penske currently advertises free unlimited mileage on one-way truck rentals. | One-way truck rentals include an allowed mileage; additional mileage can cost extra. |
| One-way rental time | Drop-off timing depends on the trip/quote; verify the included rental period. | One-way quotes include a set number of days; extra days can be purchased subject to terms/availability. |
| Local/in-town rentals | Local rental structure differs from one-way; mileage can be charged based on use. | In-town rentals return to the same location and typically involve rental plus mileage pricing. |
| Self-service | Check the pickup/return options available for the selected location. | U-Haul advertises Truck Share 24/7 mobile pickup/return availability. |
| Location network | Availability depends on Penske locations and partners in your route. | U-Haul advertises a very large U.S./Canada rental-location network. |
| Actual price | Route/date specific. Compare live quotes rather than relying on a national headline price. | |
Penske vs. U-Haul for a Long-Distance Move
For long-distance one-way moves, mileage structure can matter. Penske’s current one-way offering advertises unlimited mileage. U-Haul states that its one-way truck price includes a mileage allowance and a predetermined number of days, with charges for mileage beyond the allowance. If your route includes detours or extra driving, include that when comparing quotes.
Penske vs. U-Haul for a Local Move
For a local move, compare the base rental, mileage charge, estimated miles, rental period, fuel, coverage and equipment. A low advertised base price does not by itself tell you the final cost. Estimate the full number of miles you expect to drive—including pickup, loading, destination and return travel.
Truck Size and Availability
Do not compare prices for different-sized trucks without considering capacity. A smaller truck can look cheaper but may require multiple trips on a local move or may not fit a one-way household load. Availability also changes by location and date, so compare the truck sizes actually offered for your move.
Costs to Compare Beyond the Truck Rate
- Fuel and expected fuel economy
- Mileage allowance or per-mile charges
- Included rental days and additional-day charges
- Damage protection / coverage options
- Dollies, furniture pads and moving equipment
- Towing equipment if needed
- Taxes and applicable fees
- Pickup and drop-off logistics
Printable Penske vs. U-Haul Quote Checklist
Penske vs. U-Haul FAQ
Does Penske offer unlimited mileage?
Penske currently advertises free unlimited mileage on one-way truck rentals in the United States. Confirm the terms shown on your specific reservation.
Does U-Haul include unlimited mileage on one-way trucks?
U-Haul’s current one-way truck terms describe an allowed mileage and set number of days. Additional mileage beyond the allowance can cost extra. U-Haul trailers and towing equipment have different mileage terms.
Which is cheaper, Penske or U-Haul?
There is no universal answer because quotes vary by route, date, truck size, inventory and extras. Compare live quotes for the same move and calculate the complete trip cost.
Should I choose based only on the rental price?
No. Include mileage, days, fuel, truck capacity, coverage, equipment, pickup/drop-off logistics and likely extra charges.